Workers Speak Out to Stop the Abuse of Temporary, At-Will Workers
On April 4th at SF City Hall, over 75 members of SEIU 1021 and
IFPTE Local 21 lined up for public comment to ask the SF Board of
Supervisors Government Audit & Oversight Committee to stop the
abuse of temporary and exempt workers city workers. Temporary and
exempt workers lack job security, and most workers have fewer
benefits and protections.
“These are City Workers who keep our streets safe, help with
patients in hospitals and run popular recreational activities in
our Parks. They are frontline workers who provide direct services
to the Public,” said Theresa Rutherford, Laguna Honda Patient
Care Assistant, and SEIU 1021 Vice President of San
Francisco.
Since 2012, the city has nearly tripled its number of temporary,
or exempt, workers. For years, city administrators have been
filling long-term staffing shortages, bypassing civil-service
protections afforded to permanent employees.
“At this point I feel my position leaves me in a place of
uncertainty. And I feel utterly disposable. Don’t we
deserve job security with a passage to a permanent job with
protections,” said Connie Lee Yang, 4-year temporary RN from
Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital.
Workers are especially concerned about how the limited rights
afforded to exempt employees may be dissuading workers from
speaking out against harassment, racial discrimination, or other
misconduct in city departments.
“Temporary and exempt workers are vulnerable. If these practices
were happening in the private sector, we would condemn it and say
that it was unacceptable. We need to find solutions to weed out
systemic racism and sexism in our City, and we need to fix the
exempt and temporary issue that contributes to those systemic
problems.” Sandra Lee Fewer, presiding Supervisor of the hearing.